New Historical Fiction Books September 2026
Fall is almost here, and if you're anything like me, you're wondering where this year disappeared. It feels like we were just talking about spring releases, and now we're heading into cozy reading season. If you're looking for the best new historical fiction books publishing September 2026, you're in the right place. This month's lineup is packed with gothic novels, historical mysteries, historical horror, and unforgettable stories perfect for the transition from summer to fall. Better yet, several of these September historical fiction releases are among the year's biggest books, so now's the time to get those Libby holds ready and start building your fall TBR.
This blog is reader-supported. At no cost to you, I earn a small commission from affiliate links used in this post. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more information, visit my legal page.
The Birthing Tree
Amanda Peters
September 1 | Catapult
A moving multigenerational story about a Mi’kmaq woman returning home, The Birthing Tree is rich with the traditions and truths that shaped the roots of her family tree.
The Survivors Guild
Gabriella Saab
September 1 | Harper Muse
The Survivors Guild follows two survivors of the Titanic as they search for where they truly belongs after the devastating disaster.
The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies
Kate Westbury
September 1 | St Martin's
A fun new historical mystery series set in post-WWII Oxford, The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies follows two students recruited to uncover a Soviet spy before the investigation turns deadly.
A Time of Witches
Madeline Martin
September 1 | HTP Books
A Time of Witches is a dual-timeline story about a modern woman uncovering her connection to a seventeenth-century accused witch and the family legacy that still threatens her.
An Immaculate Deception
Isabela Livino
September 1 | Dutton
An Immaculate Deception is a debut Gothic horror set in 1870s Brazil about a pregnant young woman trapped in an isolated house alongside dangerous family secrets and something far more sinister.
Library of Forbidden Books
Mario Escobar
September 1 | Thomas Nelson
Set in 1933 Berlin, the Library of Forbidden Books is the story of a librarian who risks everything to save books targeted by the Nazi regime.
Agrippa
Robert Harris
September 1 | Doubleday
Agrippa is an intimate look at Marcus Agrippa, the soldier and strategist who helped Octavius rise as Rome descended into dictatorship.
The Barman of the Ritz
Philippe Collin
September 1 | Scribner
Set at the Ritz in Nazi occupied Paris, The Barman of the Ritz follows barman Frank Meier as he hides his Jewish identity and navigates life under Nazi rule.
Untamed Coast
Kevin C. Morris
September 1 | Ballantine
Untamed Coast is an atmospheric multi-timeline mystery set on the Alaskan coast, where one man’s search for a missing woman uncovers decades of buried secrets.
The Witches of Cambridge
Alice Hoffman
September 8 | Scribner
A historical fantasy set at 1950s Radcliffe, The Witches of Cambridge follows two young women drawn into a secret society of witches as danger begins closing in around them.
The Chinese Lady
Bo Wang
September 8 | Harpervia
Based on the true story of Afong Moy, the first Chinese woman brought to the United States, The Chinese Lady tells of her long journey to reclaim her name and her story.
The Lost Perfumes of Paris
Christine Wells
September 8 | William Morrow
Set in the glamourous world of mid-century Paris, The Lost Perfumes of Paris is the story of a young woman determined to prove herself and protect her family’s legacy.
The Pirate Queen
Ariel Lawhon
September 8 | Doubleday
A sweeping historical adventure about Grace O’Malley, The Pirate Queen of Ireland, and her fight to command her own life, fleet, and future.
The Midnight Guests
Alex Hay
September 15 | HTP Books
Set in 1926 London, The Midnight Guests is a historical mystery set over one night in a lavish London hotel, where a murder turns a glamorous opening into a deadly reckoning.
The Newer World
Sebastian Barry
September 15 | Viking
The Newer World is a post-Civil War story of one man’s journey across a changed America as he tries desperately to find his place in the newer world.
American Nightmare
Kelly McWilliams
September 15 | Crown Publishing
A light-skinned Black investigator goes undercover for the NAACP to expose lynchings and confront the terror that has followed him since childhood in American Nightmare.
A Deadly Entanglement
Cathy Pegau
September 15 | St Martin's
A Deadly Entanglement follows two queer women working together to uncover the truth about suspicious deaths linked to both a public hospital and a private clinic.
Our Noble Selves
Kate Atkinson
September 15 | Doubleday
Our Noble Selves is a thrilling postwar mystery about a journalist caught in a missing woman case while Britain tries to reinvent itself after World War II.
The Munich Affair
James Patterson & David Ellis
September 21 | Little, Brown and Company
A century-spanning historical thriller based on true events, The Munich Affair begins with a murder tied to Hitler and follows the people who risk everything to uncover the truth.
All Her Beautiful Deaths
A. Rushby
September 22 | Berkley
All Her Beautiful Deaths is a gothic dual-timeline about Victorian death photography, a house full of secrets, and the danger of uncovering what should have stayed buried.
The Vanished Sister
Sherry Thomas
September 29 | Berkley
The Vanished Sister is a Victorian era mystery in which Charlotte Holmes, aka Sherlock, investigates the disappearance of Mrs. Watson’s estranged sister during a seaside summer gathering.
Dodge City
Patrick deWitt
September 29 | Ecco
Dodge City is a rollicking road novel about a young man fleeing the Vietnam draft, crossing the country by car while confronting the family he may be leaving behind for good.
The French Innkeeper's Daughter
Diane C. McPhail
September 29 | Kensington
The French Innkeeper's Daughter is the sweeping story of a young French woman exiled to colonial Louisiana who becomes part of the origin story of New Orleans.
Heavy Cream
Sarah Blakley-Cartwright
September 29 | Simon & Schuster
Heavy Cream is a coming-of-age novel about a teenage girl abandoned in New York and the three very different women who each try to shape her future.
Before You Go
Be sure to sign up for my email newsletter, where I share updates about the latest reading wrap-ups and blog posts, must-see book deals, and behind-the-scenes updates! And for even more fun, head to BookTube, Bookstagram, or Bindery for all things bookish!
Hi, I'm Carlie
I’m a historical fiction fanatic passionate about sharing newly released books, book club picks, and the types of stories that linger long after the last lines. If that sounds like the type of books you love to read, then you’re in the right place!
Want More Book Recommendations?
