The Magnolia Palace: Book Review
Historical fiction is hands-down my favorite genre, so when NetGalley and Dutton Books offered me an Advanced Reader Copy of Fiona Davis’ novel, The Magnolia Palace, I jumped at the chance. While I love diving into backlist titles, there’s something especially exciting about getting an early look at a new release from a beloved historical fiction author. Set in early 20th-century New York amid the grandeur of the city’s elite, this novel weaves art, mystery, and high society into a captivating story that feels like a page out of an art history textbook—in the best possible way.
This blog is reader-supported. At no cost to you, I earn a small commission from affiliate links used in this post. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more information, visit my legal page.
Quick Look
- dual timeline
- NYC setting
- full of art history
- engaging mystery
Published January 25, 2022
Thanks to Dutton for the advanced access!
Publisher's Synopsis
Eight months since losing her mother in the Spanish flu outbreak of 1919, twenty-one-year-old Lillian Carter's life has completely fallen apart. For the past six years, under the moniker Angelica, Lillian was one of the most sought-after artists' models in New York City, with statues based on her figure gracing landmarks from the Plaza Hotel to the Brooklyn Bridge. But with her mother gone, a grieving Lillian is rudderless and desperate—the work has dried up and a looming scandal has left her entirely without a safe haven. So when she stumbles upon an employment opportunity at the Frick mansion—a building that, ironically, bears her own visage—Lillian jumps at the chance. But the longer she works as a private secretary to the imperious and demanding Helen Frick, the daughter and heiress of industrialist and art patron Henry Clay Frick, the more deeply her life gets intertwined with that of the family—pulling her into a tangled web of romantic trysts, stolen jewels, and family drama that runs so deep, the stakes just may be life or death.
Nearly fifty years later, mod English model Veronica Weber has her own chance to make her career—and with it, earn the money she needs to support her family back home—within the walls of the former Frick residence, now converted into one of New York City's most impressive museums. But when she—along with a charming intern/budding art curator named Joshua—is dismissed from the Vogue shoot taking place at the Frick Collection, she chances upon a series of hidden messages in the museum: messages that will lead her and Joshua on a hunt that could not only solve Veronica's financial woes, but could finally reveal the truth behind a decades-old murder in the infamous Frick family.
My Review
Historical fiction is my favorite genre, and The Magnolia Palace hits all the marks for what I consider great historical storytelling. In her author’s note, Fiona Davis shares that the inspiration for the novel came from the magnificent Frick Museum—its renowned art collection and the eccentric family behind it. If you’ve never been, I highly recommend adding it to your itinerary next time you're in New York. The Frick isn’t just a museum; it’s a step back in time. The art is breathtaking, and the mansion itself feels like a beautifully preserved piece of early 20th-century New York.
Now, back to the book: I especially loved how Davis wove art and art history into the narrative, using it to enrich the story and elevate Lillian’s character. She’s far more than a pretty face, and as the novel unfolds, we see her strength, intelligence, and resilience take center stage. One of the standout elements of the book is the evolving relationship between Lillian and Helen Frick—it’s subtle, layered, and ultimately, the emotional heart of the novel.
The contrast between these two women is striking. Lillian, though struggling when we meet her, is fiercely independent and full of grit. You can’t help but root for her as she faces each challenge with sharp instincts and unwavering determination. Helen, on the other hand, is deeply tied to her father’s influence—sheltered, approval-seeking, and hesitant to live on her own terms. Watching their bond form despite such vast differences is one of the most rewarding aspects of the story.
The dual timeline format worked seamlessly here. The transitions were smooth and well-paced, keeping me hooked and eager to return to each storyline. While the modern narrative felt a bit far-fetched at times, it added a layer of suspense and intrigue that kept the pages turning. What I appreciated most was the moral complexity woven into both timelines. Davis doesn’t spoon-feed right or wrong—she lets her characters wrestle with real dilemmas, inviting readers to reflect on what they might do in similar circumstances.
My Rating
The Magnolia Palace is a wonderful example of historical fiction done right—breathing life into the past while spotlighting one of New York’s most iconic landmarks. With a mix of mystery, betrayal, and emotion, it kept me engaged even through a few plot stretches. Perfect for fans of historical fiction, especially those who love art and art history. You might just find yourself planning a trip to the Frick Museum after reading!
Before You Go
Be sure to sign up for my email newsletter, where I share updates about the latest reading wrap-ups and blog posts, must-see book deals, and behind-the-scenes updates! And for even more fun, head to BookTube, Bookstagram, or Bindery for all things bookish!
